Newborn Toys: The Best & Safest Options for Baby

Learn how to avoid toxins lurking in many newborn toys and find the best stuffed animals, wooden, and rubber toys for baby. Plus, get safer plastic options.

What are the best newborn toys? We've got the scoop on natural toys for babies. Including natural wood toys, natural rubber toys, and organic stuffed animals for babies.

Have you ever walked down the baby toy aisle and realized that so many of those toys are made of plastic or other synthetic materials? Yikes! This might leave you wondering: What exactly is my newborn supposed to play with?! Whether you’re just starting to make your baby registry or your baby is already here and ready to play, we can help you choose the best and safest newborn toys.

In this post, we’ll cover:

  • The best toys for newborns
  • How to choose safer toys
  • Plus, why newborn toys are important

The Best Newborn Toys

A 2008 study by Michigan-based consumer-safety program called the Ecology Center discovered that about a third of all the toys tested contained potentially harmful levels of lead, cadmium, phthalates, and other harmful substances.

Unfortunately, labels can be very misleading and even things labeled “eco-friendly” may not be the best choice. Look for toys that have a GREENGUARD certification. The Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association (JPMA) and The Consumer Product Safety Commission are also excellent resources when shopping for safe newborn toys.

It may take a little detective work, but finding toys made without harmful materials is worth the effort, since babies tend to mouth, chew, or even teethe on newborn toys.

With that said, the best toys for newborns are:

Wooden newborn toys

Because even BPA-free plastic can be harmful (source), the ideal toys are made of natural wood without any paint or stain.

Consider these options:

Promise Babe 11-Piece Animal Set
Promise Babe 11-Piece Animal Set

This set of animals is easy for little hands to pick up, and as baby gets older, you can teach him the names for all of the animals.Baby Love Wooden Car: Who says that toy cars have to be metal and tiny with small parts? Your baby will love rolling this car back and forth with you.

— Check it Out —
Promise Babe 11-Piece Animal Set
Baby Love Wooden Car
Baby Love Wooden Car

Who says that toy cars have to be metal and tiny with small parts? Your baby will love rolling this car back and forth with you.

— Check it Out —
Baby Love Wooden Car
Skiwsh Natural Rattle
Skiwsh Natural Rattle

Fun to squish, this rattle encourages your baby to use the pincer grasp. The beads slide along the rods and encourage motor skill development.

— Check it Out —
Skiwsh Natural Rattle

Natural rubber newborn toys

If you’re concerned baby might hurt themself with a wooden toy, try one softer natural rubber toys that are manufactured from the sap of a Hevea tree. They should say “100 percent natural rubber.”

Consider these options:

HEVEA Natural Rubber Duck
HEVEA Natural Rubber Duck

It's hard to resist the charm of a rubber ducky. This one is suitable for playing in the tub or in the nursery.

— Check it Out —
HEVEA Natural Rubber Duck
Vulli Josephine the Mouse - HEVEA Natural Rubber Duck
Vulli Josephine the Mouse

This newborn toy is 100 percent natural rubber and colored with food-grade paint.

— Check it Out —
Vulli Josephine the Mouse - HEVEA Natural Rubber Duck
CaaOcho Sensory Ball
CaaOcho Sensory Ball

Have fun rolling this around without worrying about plastic or toxic paint. Made from 100 percent natural rubber and food-grade paint.

— Check it Out —
CaaOcho Sensory Ball
Rubbablox Natural Rubber Blocks
Rubbablox Natural Rubber Blocks

Sustainable and safe, let your baby learn the joys of knocking down a tower of blocks with these 100 percent natural rubber blocks.

— Check it Out —
Rubbablox Natural Rubber Blocks

Organic stuffed animals

It’s important to choose organic stuffed animals that contain natural materials, like 100 percent organic cotton or wool. Traditional stuffed animals usually contain flame retardants, which in studies, can affect hormone production and even lead to breast cancer. Consider these options:

John n Tree Lovely Puppy
John n Tree Lovely Puppy

Made from 100 percent organic cotton, this puppy is soft, snuggly, and super cute. Plus, it's free from flame retardants.

— Check it Out —
John n Tree Lovely Puppy
Under the Nile Scrappy Bunny
Under the Nile Scrappy Bunny

Made from 100 percent organic cotton, this bunny is so soft that it's almost velvety to the touch.

— Check it Out —
Under the Nile Scrappy Bunny
Elly Lu Cupcake the Unicorn
Elly Lu Cupcake the Unicorn

This adorable unicorn will be your baby's new best friend. Soft and cuddly with no yucky materials.

— Check it Out —
Elly Lu Cupcake the Unicorn

How to Choose Safer Plastic Newborn Toys

While avoiding plastic is ideal, sometimes you might let some plastic toys be part of your child’s collection. Here are some tips for sourcing safer plastic newborn toys.

Check the type of plastic

You’ll probably see a number in a triangle somewhere on the toy and/or the toy’s packaging. This number signifies the type of plastic used. Here are the most common types of plastic:

  • #5 polypropylene: A low-risk, heat tolerant plastic; often used for yogurt tubs. It is a suitable plastic for newborn toys. (source)
  • #2 high-density polyethylene (HDPE): This plastic is BPA-free, but some tests show it can affect hormone levels. Use with caution. (source)
  • #4 low-density polyethylene: Use with caution.
  • #3 pvc: Do not use this type of plastic. PVC, or polyvinyl chloride, is one of the most dangerous plastics, according to a study published in The Science of the Total Environment. PVC is both carcinogenic and mutagenic. (source)

Check manufacturing details

Choose toys manufactured in the U.S. Why? Although most plastic comes from China, manufacturing guidelines are stricter here.

Try these vetted plastic newborn toys

Although there aren’t many options in this category, babies don’t need an overabundance—just a few quality toys. The brand Green Toys is a parent favorite, because it’s easy-to-find and made from recycled plastic.

Green Toys Teething Toy
Green Toys Teething Toy

This lightweight, three dimensional teether is easy for tiny fingers to grasp. And, best of all, it's perfectly safe for gumming.

— Check it Out —
Green Toys Teething Toy
Green Toys My First Stacking Set
Green Toys My First Stacking Set

This fun set is made from recycled plastic and is free from BPA, phthalates, and PVC.

— Check it Out —
Green Toys My First Stacking Set
Green Toys Shape Sorter
Green Toys Shape Sorter

This all-natural toy encourages fine motor skills and color matching skills.

— Check it Out —
Green Toys Shape Sorter
Green Toys Toy Starter Set
Green Toys Toy Starter Set

This 100% recycled safe and non-toxic toy set makes the perfect baby shower gift.

— Check it Out —
Green Toys Toy Starter Set

Get free updates on baby’s first year! – Free Updates on First Year [In-article]

Sign me up!

More Quick Tips for Buying Newborn Toys

Ready to get shopping for a few new gifts or toys? Follow these guidelines:

  • Choose age-appropriate toys: Read the label for age guidelines and avoid toys with any small parts that can come off and pose a choking hazard.
  • Read the labels: Always buy products that state they are nontoxic, eco-friendly, etc. If you do have an electric toy, make sure it says “UL” approved. When your electronics are “UL approved”, it means that your product has met the safety standards of Underwriters Laboratories.
  • Avoid loud, bright toys: These toys may overstimulate sensitive newborns. Plus, these toys tend to have many plastic parts.
  • Check for product recalls before purchasing a new toy.

Why Newborn Toys Are Important

It’s tempting to throw in the towel—to feel like the effort of finding the right toy just isn’t worth it when baby is so young—but toys aren’t just for entertainment. Toys can help babies (and older children):

  • Build social skills (i.e. interacting with you!)
  • Strengthen gross motor skills, like hand-eye coordination
  • Improve fine motor skills, like their pincer grasp
  • Develop logic and problem-solving skills
  • Foster imagination and story telling

Remember…

The most important thing about playing with your newborn is bonding! Do you have any favorite natural baby toys?

Read This Next…

Genevieve Howland

About the Author

Genevieve Howland is a doula and childbirth educator. She is the bestselling author of The Mama Natural Week-by-Week Guide to Pregnancy and Childbirth and creator of the Mama Natural Birth Course. A mother of three, graduate of the University of Colorado, and YouTuber with over 135,000,000 views, she helps mothers and moms-to-be lead healthier and more natural lives.

8 Comments

  2. Hi there! Any thoughts on KiwiCo? I had a coupon so ordered my first box but can’t find anywhere on their website about their actual safety standards. Thank you!

    Reply

  3. Many of the kinks are broken xan you please update

    Reply

  4. I have seen a play gym/mat and foam floor tiles in many of your videos. Could you share the brands please!?

    Reply

  5. Be aware of the baby love wooden car. It’s a choking hazard since the wheels can fall off easily.

    Reply

  6. This is great! Do you have any suggestions for jewelry I could wear to distract my baby so she stops trying to get my hair every time I pick her up?

    Reply

    • I got one that is a mix of big food-grade silicone beads and untreated wooden beads. I got mine from “Mommy’s Beads” on Etsy; I’m sure you could find something similar if you wanted! There are also some cotton-covered bead necklaces that look fun for baby to fiddle with but still good materials/choking safe.

      Reply

  7. Do you have an opinion or thoughts on Lovevery?

    Reply

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published. All fields are required *

*

Get free baby updates from Mama Natural

Hey Mama! Get my FREE baby updates every week!

  • Track baby’s development
  • Discover safe & natural remedies
  • Access free tools & resources

SIGN ME UP!

Not on Messenger? .